Mortgage Lenders and Brokers in Buffalo, Indiana
Brian McKay
|
iEditorial Disclosure
Editorial DisclosureLender lists come from federal HMDA loan data. Average rates come from our daily monitoring network. Editorial content is independent of any advertiser relationships.
|
✓Fact Checked
|
Loan Rates Last Updated and Verified: October 7, 2026
Buffalo, Indiana mortgage lenders include First Merchants BankFirst Merchants Bank800 Main St Ste 100, Anderson, IN 46016A+5.0 ★Texas Ratio: 4.12%, Bank of WolcottBank of Wolcott116 N 6th St, Monticello, IN 47960A+5.0 ★Texas Ratio: 2.72%, The Fountain Trust CompanyThe Fountain Trust Company427 E Main St, Attica, IN 47918A+5.0 ★Texas Ratio: 3.40%, Centier BankCentier Bank1000 East Main Street, Brownsburg, IN 46112A5.0 ★Texas Ratio: 6.45%, Security Federal Savings BankSecurity Federal Savings Bank1260 S Washington St, Delphi, IN 46923A+5.0 ★Texas Ratio: 2.60%, Flagstar Bank NAFlagstar Bank NA2204 N Wayne St, Angola, IN 46703D3.3 ★Texas Ratio: 35.11%, First Financial BankFirst Financial Bank104 Linksway, Aurora, IN 47001A+5.0 ★Texas Ratio: 3.21%, Alliance BankAlliance Bank101 W Montgomery St, Francesville, IN 47946A+5.0 ★Texas Ratio: 0.08%, Fifth Third Bank, National AssociationFifth Third Bank, National Association100 Growth Pkwy, Angola, IN 46703A+5.0 ★Texas Ratio: 3.22%, and US Bank, N.A.US Bank, N.A.720 W 30th St, Connersville, IN 47331A+5.0 ★Texas Ratio: 2.85%. Banks, credit unions and mortgage companies are listed together, with FHA, VA and local options flagged for quick comparison.
Lenders are ranked only by the number of home loans they closed in Buffalo, Indiana in 2025, as reported under the federal Home Mortgage Disclosure Act. No lender pays for a higher spot. Lenders based in Buffalo are listed first, then lenders elsewhere in Indiana, then lenders from other states that closed loans there. Banks and credit unions carry a MonitorBankRates health grade, star rating and Texas Ratio, so you can judge how financially sound they are. Mortgage companies have no deposits to rate, so compare their loan programs, median loan and borrower reviews instead. Compare at least three lenders and ask each for a written loan estimate before you choose.
Mortgage Lenders and Brokers in Buffalo, Indiana
Market share is the lender's share of all home loans closed in Buffalo, Indiana. Approval share is approvals divided by completed applications. Grade is the MonitorBankRates Health and Safety Grade, available for banks and credit unions only. Average loan is the lender's mean loan amount here.
| Lender | Programs | Loans closed | Market share | Approval share | Average loan | View |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|
800 Main St Ste 100, Anderson, IN 46016 A+5.0 ★Texas Ratio: 4.12% |
Conventional, HELOC | 3 +6 HELOCs |
5.3% | 100% | $138,333 | View |
|
116 N 6th St, Monticello, IN 47960 A+5.0 ★Texas Ratio: 2.72% |
Conventional | 2 | 3.5% | 100% | $150,000 | View |
|
427 E Main St, Attica, IN 47918 A+5.0 ★Texas Ratio: 3.40% |
Conventional | 2 | 3.5% | 100% | $60,000 | View |
|
1000 East Main Street, Brownsburg, IN 46112 A5.0 ★Texas Ratio: 6.45% |
Conventional | 2 | 3.5% | 100% | $320,000 | View |
|
1260 S Washington St, Delphi, IN 46923 A+5.0 ★Texas Ratio: 2.60% |
Conventional, HELOC | 1 +1 HELOCs |
1.8% | 100% | $135,000 | View |
|
2204 N Wayne St, Angola, IN 46703 D3.3 ★Texas Ratio: 35.11% |
Conventional | 1 | 1.8% | 100% | $45,000 | View |
|
104 Linksway, Aurora, IN 47001 A+5.0 ★Texas Ratio: 3.21% |
Conventional | 1 | 1.8% | 100% | $445,000 | View |
|
101 W Montgomery St, Francesville, IN 47946 A+5.0 ★Texas Ratio: 0.08% |
Conventional | 1 | 1.8% | 100% | $205,000 | View |
|
100 Growth Pkwy, Angola, IN 46703 A+5.0 ★Texas Ratio: 3.22% |
Conventional | 1 | 1.8% | 100% | $65,000 | View |
|
720 W 30th St, Connersville, IN 47331 A+5.0 ★Texas Ratio: 2.85% |
HELOC | 0 +1 HELOCs |
0% | n/a | View | |
|
7503 Beechwood Centre Rd, Avon, IN 46123 A+5.0 ★Texas Ratio: 3.54% |
HELOC | 0 +1 HELOCs |
0% | n/a | View | |
|
7607 E US Highway 36, Avon, IN 46123 A5.0 ★Texas Ratio: 6.81% |
HELOC | 0 +1 HELOCs |
0% | n/a | View | |
|
★ 1.7 stars, 3 reviews 111 N Harrison St, Alexandria, IN 46001 A+5.0 ★Texas Ratio: 4.24% |
HELOC | 0 +1 HELOCs |
0% | n/a | View | |
Industrial Federal C. U.
|
Conventional | 3 | 5.3% | 100% | $45,000 | |
Royal United Mortgage LLC
|
Conventional | 1 | 1.8% | 50% | $105,000 | |
Gvc Mortgage, Inc.
|
Conventional | 1 | 1.8% | 100% | $195,000 | |
Mortgage Research Center
|
Conventional, FHA, VA | 6 | 10.5% | 100% | $208,333 | |
United Wholesale Mortgage
|
Conventional | 4 | 7% | 100% | $175,000 | |
Rocket Mortgage
|
Conventional, FHA | 4 | 7% | 80% | $147,500 | |
American Financial Network, Inc.
|
Conventional, FHA | 3 | 5.3% | 100% | $185,000 | |
Credit Union 1
|
Conventional, HELOC | 1 +1 HELOCs |
1.8% | 100% | $75,000 | |
|
A+5.0 ★Texas Ratio: 0.14% |
Conventional | 1 | 1.8% | 100% | $355,000 | View |
Greenstate Credit Union
|
Conventional | 1 | 1.8% | 100% | $365,000 | |
Gold Star Mortgage Financial Group, Corporation
|
Conventional | 1 | 1.8% | 100% | $335,000 | |
Lakeview Loan Servicing, LLC
|
FHA | 1 | 1.8% | 100% | $135,000 | |
Newrez LLC
|
FHA | 1 | 1.8% | 100% | $155,000 | |
Equity Prime Mortgage LLC
|
FHA | 1 | 1.8% | 100% | $205,000 | |
Amerisave Mortgage Company
|
Conventional | 1 | 1.8% | 100% | $65,000 | |
loanDepot.com LLC
|
Conventional | 1 | 1.8% | 100% | $285,000 | |
Union Home Mortgage Corp.
|
Conventional | 1 | 1.8% | 100% | $295,000 | |
American Pacific Mortgage Corporation
|
FHA | 1 | 1.8% | 100% | $165,000 | |
|
B4.4 ★Texas Ratio: 21.68% |
FHA | 1 | 1.8% | 100% | $195,000 | View |
Nationstar Mortgage
|
Conventional | 1 | 1.8% | 100% | $135,000 | |
Member First Mortgage, LLC
|
Conventional | 1 | 1.8% | 50% | $15,000 | |
Prosperity Home Mortgage, LLC
|
FHA | 1 | 1.8% | 100% | $235,000 | |
New American Funding, LLC.
|
FHA | 1 | 1.8% | 100% | $115,000 | |
|
A+5.0 ★Texas Ratio: 2.14% |
VA | 1 | 1.8% | 100% | $205,000 | View |
Navy Federal Credit Union
|
VA | 1 | 1.8% | 100% | $225,000 | |
21St Mortgage
|
Conventional | 1 | 1.8% | 100% | $175,000 | |
Carrington Mortgage Services LLC
|
Conventional | 1 | 1.8% | 100% | $55,000 | |
Leaderone Financial Corp.
|
Conventional | 1 | 1.8% | 100% | $235,000 | |
Cmg Mortgage Inc
|
HELOC | 0 +1 HELOCs |
0% | 0% |
Buffalo Mortgage Rate Trends
Daily average mortgage rates for Indiana compared with the national average, updated every evening.
Mortgage Lenders and Mortgage Brokers Near Me in Buffalo, Indiana
Looking for mortgage lenders near me or mortgage brokers near me in Buffalo? The list below shows the banks, credit unions and mortgage brokers that closed home loans in Buffalo in 2025, with lenders based there listed first.
Types of Mortgage Lenders in Buffalo, IN
Use these to narrow the list above. Each category shows how many Buffalo, IN lenders fit and what that kind of lender is usually best for.
Who Lends in Buffalo, IN
Independent mortgage companies closed 59.6 percent of home loans in Buffalo, Indiana in 2025, banks 29.8 percent and credit unions 10.5 percent. Royal United Mortgage LLC was the largest mortgage company, First Merchants Bank the largest bank and Everwise Credit Union the largest credit union. Among lenders headquartered in Indiana, First Merchants Bank led with 3 loans.
How to Read This List
A high approval share with a small median loan usually points to a lender comfortable with first time and FHA borrowers. A large median loan with conventional and jumbo programs points to a move up and jumbo specialist. The health grade says whether a bank or credit union is financially sound; it says nothing about service, which is what the reviews below are for.
Title or escrow companies usually handle closings in Indiana. None
More Indiana Mortgage Lender Pages
Frequently Asked Questions About Mortgage Lenders in Buffalo, IN
By home loans closed in 2025, First Merchants Bank was the largest mortgage lender in Buffalo, Indiana with 3 loans, about 5.3 percent of the market. Source: Home Mortgage Disclosure Act data for 2025, published by the FFIEC and CFPB.
10 lenders closed FHA loans in Buffalo, Indiana in 2025, led by Mortgage Research Center with 1. 3 lenders closed VA loans, led by Mortgage Research Center. Use the FHA and VA filters above the table to see only those lenders; FHA loans allow 3.5 percent down and lower credit scores, VA loans need no down payment for eligible veterans. Source: Home Mortgage Disclosure Act data for 2025, published by the FFIEC and CFPB.
Yes. 15 banks and 5 credit unions closed home loans in Buffalo, Indiana in 2025, alongside 22 independent mortgage companies and brokers. Banks and credit unions carry a MonitorBankRates health grade. Mortgage companies are not deposit institutions, so they have no health grade; their HMDA figures and borrower reviews stand in. Source: Home Mortgage Disclosure Act data for 2025, published by the FFIEC and CFPB.
Lenders are ranked only by the number of home loans they closed in Buffalo, Indiana during 2025 as reported under the federal Home Mortgage Disclosure Act. No lender pays to be listed or to rank higher, and reviews do not change the order. Counts cover first and second lien loans on one to four unit homes for purchase, refinance and home improvement; home equity lines are counted separately.
Methodology and Sources
Lender rankings use the loan level records that lenders file under the Home Mortgage Disclosure Act, published by the FFIEC and the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau for the 2025 reporting year. Counts include originated first and subordinate lien loans on one to four unit homes in Buffalo, Indiana for purchase, refinance and other purposes; home equity lines of credit are counted separately and reverse mortgages and business purpose loans are excluded. Approval share is originations plus approved but not accepted applications divided by all completed applications (withdrawn and incomplete files are excluded). Lender type comes from the lender's federal regulator and the FFIEC National Information Center. City figures use the Census tracts that make up Buffalo. Health grades are MonitorBankRates data and are current as of the date shown. Lenders below the HMDA reporting thresholds do not appear. MonitorBankRates receives no payment for placement on this page. Last updated October 8, 2026.
