MonitorBankRates
☰
New Compare more than 4,500 CD specials and promotional CD rates from banks and credit unions on our new CD Specials page. See CD specials
  1. Home›
  2. Mortgage Lenders›
  3. Fay Servicing
iAdvertiser Disclosure
Advertiser Disclosure Some lenders listed may have a business relationship with MonitorBankRates. Our proprietary systems independently track and verify all rates. Advertiser relationships do not influence the lending data, reviews or rates shown.

Fay Servicing Review: Mortgage Rates, Loans and Lending Data November 2026

Fay Servicing mortgage rates are not currently in the MonitorBankRates database, but you can compare mortgage rates from banks and credit unions MonitorBankRates tracks, including 6.25% on 30-year fixed mortgages, 5.675% on 15-year fixed mortgages, 5.114% on 5-year ARMs, 6.50% on FHA loans, 6.25% on VA loans and 5.24% on 30-year jumbo mortgages. Fay Servicing (Fay Servicing LLC) is a mortgage company headquartered in Tampa, FL. It closed 62 home loans in 2025, ranking #3,299 among U.S. mortgage lenders by loan count, with loans in 17 states, led by Illinois (8), Texas (8) and Florida (7). It approved 35.2 percent of completed applications. Database rates last updated and verified on 11/19/2026.

Home Loans Closed ?
62
62 loans #3,299 in the U.S. in 2025
Approval Rate ?
35%
35.2% approved of completed applications
Where Fay Servicing Lends ?
17
17 states with loans in 2025
By state ›
Fay Servicing LLC
5426 Bay Center Drive Suite 300
Tampa, FL 33609
Customer Reviews
Be the first to review
Write a Review
Lending data as of 2025 (Home Mortgage Disclosure Act loan records Fay Servicing LLC filed for calendar year 2025). This is the most recent HMDA data available. The FFIEC and CFPB publish each year's HMDA data the following year.

Current Rate Availability

We're not currently displaying rates for Fay Servicing, but our database is updated constantly, so check back soon for the latest offers.

Are you with Fay Servicing? We'd be happy to add your company's rates. Contact us to get your company's rates listed on MonitorBankRates.

Fay Servicing Mortgage, Refinance and Home Equity Rates

Fay Servicing Mortgage Rates

On the 62 home loans Fay Servicing closed in 2025, its typical interest rate was about 6.43%, 0.08 points below the typical rate in the states where it lends (HMDA). MonitorBankRates doesn't track Fay Servicing's current rates, so ask Fay Servicing for a quote and compare it with today's mortgage rates from other lenders. Compare today's mortgage rates.

Fay Servicing Refinance Rates

Fay Servicing closed 57 refinance loans in 2025, 92% of its home loans (HMDA). MonitorBankRates doesn't track Fay Servicing's refinance rates, so compare a quote from Fay Servicing with today's refinance rates from banks and credit unions. Compare today's refinance rates.

Fay Servicing Home Equity Loan and HELOC Rates

Fay Servicing didn't report any home equity loans or HELOCs in 2025 (HMDA). MonitorBankRates doesn't track Fay Servicing's home equity rates, so compare a quote with today's home equity loan and HELOC rates. Compare today's home equity rates.

Fay Servicing FHA and VA Loan Rates

In 2025, Fay Servicing closed 11 FHA loans and 4 VA loans (HMDA). FHA loans allow down payments as low as 3.5%, and VA loans are for eligible service members and veterans, often with no down payment.

Current rates are the lender's published rates as verified by MonitorBankRates. Loan counts and typical rates come from the lender's 2025 Home Mortgage Disclosure Act filings and are not current quotes.

Fay Servicing Review: Pros, Cons & Our Verdict

2.6/5
MonitorBankRates score

Our Verdict

Fay Servicing earns a MonitorBankRates score of 2.6 out of 5, based on the 62 home loans it reported closing in 2025. Its strongest area is loan variety (4 of 6 major loan types (conventional, FHA, VA, USDA, jumbo, HELOC)), and its weakest is approval rate (35.2% approved, 44.1 points below the average in its states). Rates and costs depend on your credit, down payment and loan, so compare quotes from several lenders.

Interest rates 30%3.6
Median rate 0.08 points below the typical rate in its states
Closing costs 25%1.9
Median costs about $7,620 vs. $6,230 typical
Approval rate 20%1.0
35.2% approved, 44.1 points below the average in its states
Loan variety 15%4.0
4 of 6 major loan types (conventional, FHA, VA, USDA, jumbo, HELOC)
Availability 10%3.0
Loans closed in 17 states in 2025

Pros

No standout strengths in the 2025 data.

Cons

  • Approved 35.2% of completed applications, below the 79.4% average in its states
  • Higher closing costs: a median of $7,620 vs. about $6,230 at other lenders in its states
  • No home equity lines of credit (HELOCs) in 2025
How we score: each lender's 2025 HMDA filings are compared with every lender in the same states, weighted by where it made its loans. Interest rates 30%, closing costs 25%, approval rate 20%, loan variety 15%, availability 10%. Median rates and costs also reflect the borrowers a lender serves, so treat them as a guide and compare your own quotes.

Where Fay Servicing Lends

  • Illinois 12.9%8 loans · #578 in state
  • Texas 12.9%8 loans · #847 in state
  • Florida 11.3%7 loans · #789 in state
  • Georgia 8.1%5 loans · #605 in state
  • Ohio 8.1%5 loans · #558 in state
  • Virginia 6.5%4 loans · #553 in state
  • California 4.8%3 loans · #681 in state
  • 10 other states 35.5%22 loans
See all 17 states: loans, rank, approval, median rate and costs
State Loans Closed State Rank Approval Median Loan Median Rate Median Costs Loan Types
Illinois 8 #578 of 932 50% $235,000 6.375% $5,750 Conventional, FHA
Texas 8 #847 of 1,264 30.3% $255,000 6.75% $8,500 Conventional, Jumbo
Florida 7 #789 of 1,647 22.2% $265,000 6.50% $8,750 Conventional, FHA
Georgia 5 #605 of 951 29.4% $205,000 6.25% $8,250 FHA, VA
Ohio 5 #558 of 868 62.5% $165,000 6.75% $7,250 Conventional, VA
Virginia 4 #553 of 802 33.3% $105,000 5.875% $5,750 Conventional, VA
California 3 #681 of 861 18.8% $725,000 5.875% $16,250 Conventional, FHA
Michigan 3 #535 of 765 37.5% $95,000 6.75% $3,500 Conventional, FHA
North Carolina 3 #669 of 1,003 37.5% $485,000 6.50% $10,000 Conventional, FHA
Pennsylvania 3 #701 of 905 50% $155,000 6.25% $6,500 Conventional
Alabama 2 #576 of 790 50% $85,000 6.25% $5,750 Conventional, VA
Colorado 2 #607 of 874 66.7% $305,000 6.125% $8,250 Conventional
Indiana 2 #618 of 807 25% $155,000 6.125% $6,000 Conventional, FHA
Kentucky 2 #498 of 667 66.7% $195,000 6.625% $8,000 Conventional, FHA
Minnesota 2 #559 of 711 100% $165,000 5.75% $4,500 Conventional, Jumbo
New Jersey 2 #564 of 683 50% $405,000 7.50% $8,750 Conventional, Jumbo
Oklahoma 1 #582 of 644 100% $165,000 6.625% $5,500 Conventional

Fay Servicing Lending Details

Closing likelihood
91.2%
Approved applications that closed, vs. 95.2% at all lenders
Withdrawn or incomplete
58.8%
Applications the borrower withdrew or never finished, vs. 22.1% at all lenders
Approval rate, age 62 and older
33.8%
65 completed applications, vs. 75.1% at all lenders; 35.2% for all its applicants

Home Purchase Loan Mix

Conventional80% (4)
FHA20% (1)
VA0% (0)
USDA0% (0)
Source: Home Mortgage Disclosure Act data for 2025 (FFIEC and CFPB). Age 62 and older figures cover applicants HMDA flags as 62 or older. HMDA does not include credit scores, so differences can reflect the borrowers a lender attracts.

Manage Your Fay Servicing Loan

Fay Servicing loginUse the customer login on Fay Servicing's website or the link in your loan emails
Make a paymentPay online after signing in, or by mail using the address on your monthly statement
Payoff requestRequest a payoff statement from Fay Servicing or your current servicer
Address5426 Bay Center Drive Suite 300, Tampa, FL 33609

Mortgage lenders often sell loans or move servicing to another company after closing. If that happened to your loan, your monthly mortgage statement shows the servicer to pay, sign in with and contact.

Fay Servicing Mortgagee Clause and Homeowners Insurance

A mortgagee clause is the part of your homeowners insurance policy that names your lender, so the lender is paid if the home is damaged or destroyed. It lists the lender's legal name, usually followed by ISAOA/ATIMA ("its successors and/or assigns, as their interests may appear"), and the lender's insurance mailing address, which is often a separate PO box rather than its headquarters.

To get the Fay Servicing mortgagee clause, check the homeowners insurance requirements your lender sends before closing or your closing documents, or ask Fay Servicing directly. If your loan has been sold or transferred, use the clause from your current servicer, shown on your monthly mortgage statement.

Homeowners insurance in Fay Servicing's largest states

StateMedian premiumShare of incomeBurden index
Illinois $1,446/yr 1.73% 94.6 Moderate Compare Illinois rates
Texas $2,173/yr 2.77% 165.5 Severe Compare Texas rates
Florida $2,104/yr 2.82% 162.7 Severe Compare Florida rates
Georgia $1,595/yr 2.06% 106.1 Moderate Compare Georgia rates
Ohio $1,203/yr 1.69% 89.1 Moderate Compare Ohio rates
Virginia $1,327/yr 1.42% 73.2 Low Compare Virginia rates

The MonitorBankRates Home Insurance Burden Index compares premiums with income and home values. 100 is the national baseline; higher means insurance takes a bigger bite. Source: U.S. Census Bureau data compiled by MonitorBankRates.

Compare Fay Servicing With Other Lenders

Compare today's mortgage and refinance rates from banks and credit unions in the states where Fay Servicing makes the most loans, then estimate your Fay Servicing mortgage payment with the MonitorBankRates mortgage calculator.

Lender Profile & Overview

Lender NameFay Servicing LLC
WebsiteN/A
Headquarters5426 Bay Center Drive Suite 300, Tampa, FL 33609
Lender TypeMortgage company
NMLS IDN/A
Legal Entity Identifier (LEI)549300D0H09HSURFXA20
Deposit InsuranceNot applicable (mortgage lender, does not take deposits)

Lending

Home Loans Closed (2025)
62
U.S. Rank by Loans Closed
#3,299
Approval Rate
35.2%
Closing Likelihood
91.2%
Approval Rate, Age 62+
33.8%
Purchase Loans
5
Refinance Loans
57
Loan Types Closed
Conventional, FHA, VA, Jumbo
States With Loans
17
Source: Home Mortgage Disclosure Act data (FFIEC and CFPB) — 2025 reporting year

Methodology & Data Sources

Lending Data
Loan counts, approval rates, median loan amounts and loan types for Fay Servicing come from the loan-level records it filed under the Home Mortgage Disclosure Act for 2025, published by the FFIEC and the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau. Counts cover originated first and subordinate lien loans on one to four unit homes.
MonitorBankRates Score
The score and the pros and cons compare Fay Servicing's 2025 HMDA filings with every lender in the same states, weighted by where it made its loans: median interest rate (30%), median total loan costs (25%), approval rate (20%), loan variety (15%) and availability (10%). Each category is scored 1 to 5. No lender pays for its score.
Rate Data Aggregation
When shown, Fay Servicing rates are gathered with our proprietary online rate aggregation technology and verified against the lender's own website.
Disclaimer: Interest rates are variable and subject to change without notice. Fay Servicing does not pay for this page or its placement.

Customer Reviews

There are no reviews for Fay Servicing yet. Feel free to create one below.

Review Fay Servicing

Reviews appear after a quick check for spam. We do not edit reviews or remove them for being negative.

Frequently Asked Questions About Fay Servicing

What states does Fay Servicing lend in?

In 2025, Fay Servicing closed home loans in 17 states: Illinois, Texas, Florida, Georgia, Ohio, Virginia, California, Michigan, North Carolina, Pennsylvania, Alabama, Colorado, Indiana, Kentucky, Minnesota, New Jersey and Oklahoma. Source: Home Mortgage Disclosure Act data for 2025, published by the FFIEC and CFPB.

How many mortgages did Fay Servicing close?

Fay Servicing closed 62 home loans in 2025, ranking #3,299 nationally by loan count. Its largest states were Illinois (8), Texas (8) and Florida (7). Source: Home Mortgage Disclosure Act data for 2025, published by the FFIEC and CFPB.

What types of mortgages does Fay Servicing offer?

In 2025, Fay Servicing closed Conventional, FHA, VA and Jumbo loans, including 5 purchase loans and 57 refinances. These figures show what the lender actually closed; check with Fay Servicing for its current loan programs. Source: Home Mortgage Disclosure Act data for 2025, published by the FFIEC and CFPB.

What is Fay Servicing's mortgage approval rate?

Fay Servicing approved 35.2 percent of completed mortgage applications in 2025 (68 of 193). Approval share reflects the applicants a lender attracts as much as its underwriting, so compare it alongside rates and loan programs. Source: Home Mortgage Disclosure Act data for 2025, published by the FFIEC and CFPB.

Is Fay Servicing a good mortgage lender?

Fay Servicing earns a MonitorBankRates score of 2.6 out of 5, based on the 62 home loans it reported closing in 2025. Its strongest area is loan variety (4 of 6 major loan types (conventional, FHA, VA, USDA, jumbo, HELOC)), and its weakest is approval rate (35.2% approved, 44.1 points below the average in its states). Rates and costs depend on your credit, down payment and loan, so compare quotes from several lenders. Source: Home Mortgage Disclosure Act data for 2025, published by the FFIEC and CFPB.

What are the pros and cons of Fay Servicing?

Cons: Approved 35.2% of completed applications, below the 79.4% average in its states; Higher closing costs: a median of $7,620 vs. about $6,230 at other lenders in its states; No home equity lines of credit (HELOCs) in 2025. Source: Home Mortgage Disclosure Act data for 2025, published by the FFIEC and CFPB.

What is the Fay Servicing mortgagee clause?

The Fay Servicing mortgagee clause is the lender name and address your homeowners insurance policy must list so Fay Servicing is paid if the home is damaged. It is usually Fay Servicing LLC ISAOA/ATIMA followed by Fay Servicing's insurance mailing address, which can differ from its headquarters. Find the exact clause in the homeowners insurance requirements Fay Servicing sends before closing or in your closing documents, or ask Fay Servicing. If your loan was sold or transferred, use your current servicer's clause from your mortgage statement.

How do I log in to my Fay Servicing account?

Sign in through the customer login on Fay Servicing's website, or use the link in your loan emails. If your loan was sold or transferred to another servicer, your monthly mortgage statement shows who to pay and how to sign in.

How do I make a Fay Servicing mortgage payment?

Pay online through your Fay Servicing customer account, or by mail using the payment address on your monthly statement. To pay off your loan, request a payoff statement from Fay Servicing or your current servicer. If your loan was sold or transferred to another servicer, your monthly mortgage statement shows who to pay and how to sign in.

Where is Fay Servicing located?

Fay Servicing (Fay Servicing LLC) is headquartered at 5426 Bay Center Drive Suite 300, Tampa, FL 33609. It made home loans in 17 states in 2025.

Does Fay Servicing offer refinancing?

Yes. Fay Servicing closed 57 refinance loans in 2025, 92% of its home loans. Compare refinance rates from banks and credit unions on MonitorBankRates before you apply. Source: Home Mortgage Disclosure Act data for 2025, published by the FFIEC and CFPB.

Is there a Fay Servicing mortgage calculator?

You can estimate a Fay Servicing mortgage payment with the MonitorBankRates mortgage calculator at https://www.monitorbankrates.com/calculators/mortgage. Enter the home price, down payment and the rate Fay Servicing quotes you to see your monthly payment.

How much is homeowners insurance where Fay Servicing lends?

In Illinois, the state where Fay Servicing made the most home loans, the median homeowners insurance premium is $1,446 a year, or 1.73% of median household income, with a MonitorBankRates Home Insurance Burden Index score of 94.6 (moderate; 100 is the national baseline). Source: U.S. Census Bureau data compiled by MonitorBankRates.

What are Fay Servicing's mortgage rates?

On the 62 home loans Fay Servicing closed in 2025, its typical interest rate was about 6.43%, 0.08 points below the typical rate in the states where it lends (HMDA). MonitorBankRates doesn't track Fay Servicing's current rates, so ask Fay Servicing for a quote and compare it with today's mortgage rates from other lenders.

What are Fay Servicing's refinance rates?

Fay Servicing closed 57 refinance loans in 2025, 92% of its home loans (HMDA). MonitorBankRates doesn't track Fay Servicing's refinance rates, so compare a quote from Fay Servicing with today's refinance rates from banks and credit unions.

What are Fay Servicing's home equity loan and HELOC rates?

Fay Servicing didn't report any home equity loans or HELOCs in 2025 (HMDA). MonitorBankRates doesn't track Fay Servicing's home equity rates, so compare a quote with today's home equity loan and HELOC rates.

What are Fay Servicing's FHA and VA loan rates?

In 2025, Fay Servicing closed 11 FHA loans and 4 VA loans (HMDA). FHA loans allow down payments as low as 3.5%, and VA loans are for eligible service members and veterans, often with no down payment.

Does Fay Servicing pay to be listed on MonitorBankRates?

No. Lender pages and rankings on MonitorBankRates come from federal HMDA loan data and our own rate monitoring. No lender pays for placement, and borrower reviews are shown whether positive or negative after a check for spam.